A fifth North Korean nuclear test could trigger new sanctions including an effort to choke off hard currency earnings by its laborers abroad, the top U.S. diplomat for the Asia-Pacific region said on Tuesday.
“Like a regimen of medicine, the dosage can be upped when the effects fall short of what’s required,” Assistant Secretary of State for East Asian and Pacific Affairs Danny Russel told Reuters.
Russel made clear he was speaking about the possibility of fresh sanctions by the U.N. Security Council, by the United States on its own, or by a group of like-minded states from the European Union and Southeast Asia, along with the United States.
North Korea conducted a fourth nuclear test in January and a long-range rocket launch the following month, triggering expanded U.N. sanctions aimed at starving it of funds for its atomic weapons program.
Some experts expect North Korea to conduct a fifth nuclear test in the near future, possibly before its party congress in early May, following an embarrassing failure of a test of an intermediate-range missile last week.
The effectiveness of current, or any new, sanctions depends heavily on them being fully implemented by China, North Korea’s neighbor, the closest thing it has to an ally and by far its largest trading partner, U.S. officials and analysts say.
If the North were to test a fifth nuclear device, the United States and its allies South Korea and Japan could also take unspecified “defense-related measures,” Russel said.
“As the threat grows, then our defensive capabilities need to adjust as well,” he said, stressing that there was also a diplomatic route that the North could take by reviving long-dormant negotiations on curbing its nuclear program.
Russel laid out what he called the possible “universe” of how the U.S. government and others might respond to a fifth test and he acknowledged that sanctions have failed to deter North Korea, which tested its first nuclear device in October 2006. He stressed that no decisions had yet been made and said he could not preview a response to an event that has yet to occur.
U.S. General Vincent Brooks, whom President Barack Obama has nominated to lead American forces in South Korea, said on Tuesday that China was frustrated over North Korea’s behavior, including its nuclear advances, but was unwilling to apply pressure that could threaten the viability of Kim Jong Un’s government.
Russel said it would take time to judge how well the latest sanctions were being enforced, but Beijing had “exhausted traditional options of encouraging and cajoling and persuading the North Koreans and they have clearly shifted to the application of pressure.”
“There is an argument to be made that serious and sustained pressure on North Korea has never before been undertaken,” he said. “The degree to which the North Korean economy depends on China and access to China is such that this stated resolve on the part of China, I think, constitutes something of a new ball game.”
However, Frank Jannuzi, a former Senate Foreign Relations Committee staffer for East Asia and the Pacific, voiced skepticism that China had had a change of heart and was now willing to apply much more significant pressure on the North.
“The Chinese are the one country that still has economic leverage but they are reluctant to put it to full use because they don’t think it’ll work and they are worried about the costs,” he said, citing long-standing Chinese fears that severe sanctions could trigger “conflict, or refugees, or turmoil.”